Blackmailed by the Babysitter
Your babysitter found your hidden cameras and all the videos of her you have! No one would expect such a good Christian family man to be a closet pervert. Wouldn’t it be horrible if your wife found out? What would she do to you if I showed her? How much would you pay me to not destroy your life? You know your wife really would do that. She’d probably tell all your friends what a unfaithful husband you are and how creepy it is that you spied on the babysitter. You’re disgusting for doing that. The only thing that could ever fix it is paying me more money. I wouldn’t want to be a home wrecker or anything like that, so don’t make me do that to you.